News: August 2009 Archives

...whether they are dealing with Health Care or Real Estate Services.

I was chatting with a friend of mine last week when he admitted that he had been without health insurance since he got out of college. Given that he's a real estate agent, that's not so surprising: as an independent contractor he's on his own regarding health insurance and many in our industry have simply taken their chances, especially when they are young and healthy like my friend Jack.

But as part of the approximately 15% of Americans who are uninsured, Jack has a window on a phenomenon that few of the rest of us ever see: what health services actually cost. You see, Jack was playing softball one Saturday a couple of weeks ago and sprained his ankle. As luck would have it, a member of the team was a physician and offered to take a look at the ankle at his office. After his ankle was wrapped up, Jack offered to pay him. 

But here's the interesting phenomenon: the doctor-teammate didn't have a clue as to what to charge him because he had no clue as to what his services were worth! As any doctor today will tell you: their charges are handled by insurance. And the truth is that if the good doctor had not been playing softball with him, Jack's lack of insurance would have dictated that he wouldn't be going to a doctor's office at all - rather he would have to go to the ER if he wanted his ankle looked at and the cost of his care at the ER would have been absorbed by the insured.

Meanwhile, most of us who have health insurance never ask a doctor what they charge because we don't pay for the lion's share of our care - insurance does, so we have been quietly oblivious until the last few years.

So, what does this have to do with real estate?

As I write this, the US government is embroiled in wrangling over how to overhaul our health care system. It seems to me that the system is not so much broken as it is hopelessly dated because as times changed, it never adapted. Our health care system was designed in years past, when you would hold a job for a lifetime. In that world, it made perfect sense to have your health care as a benefit of that job. But how many of us today stay in one job for our entire lives? And what about the growing legions of independent contractors and self employed entrepreneurs who have no access to a "company" plan? Health care tied to one's employment makes about as much sense in today's world as using a typewriter to write a letter.

Likewise, in the real estate industry, we continue to practice in a way that is not so much broken but hopelessly outdated. The traditional sales model was conceived in years past when we, as real estate practitioners had a very different role. If you think about it, real estate as a sales profession, paid by commission, made total sense when the agent's only job was to "move the merchandise". But in the 1990's our national and state associations expanded our role - it was no longer enough to simply sell the product, we now were asked to act as fiduciaries: working in the best interest of our client and putting their needs above all others, including, and most especially our own. In fact, our responsibilities as a fiduciary became a part of the NAR's (National Association of Realtors®) code of ethics that we are obliged to adhere to.

Yet, when our role was expanded and fundamentally changed, when we were asked to provide objective counsel that was in the client's best interest, no attention was given to how this new role fit with a compensation system that is geared toward salespeople who are free to work in their own best interest. Consequently, real estate professionals today are put in an impossible bind that no amount of "ethics training" can address: we are being asked to provide objective counsel that is in the best interest of our client when how much we are paid, (or whether we are paid at all) is wholly dependent on the client's decisions which we are advising them on!